In an interview with Radio.com last month, Aldean talked of "When She Says Baby," his fifth radio single off of his album Night Train. "It's just one of those songs that on the [album] that kinda grew on me," he said. "You have certain songs that grow on you and certain songs that you kinda fall off of after a while. And this was one that, after listening to it for a year, I'm still into it. And that's usually the sign of a good song."

Aldean admitted "When She Says Baby," which was written by Rhett Akins and Ben Hayslip, two-thirds of the hit songwriting trio the Peach Pickers, was a song that he needed to spend a little time with before understanding how good it was.