Courts Allowing Rap Lyrics as Evidence in Criminal Trials
A recent op-ed in the New York Times points out how one Vonte Skinner was convicted in a New Jersey courtroom of attempted murder of a rival drug dealer in large part based on extremely violent rap lyrics he'd written. The lyrics were found in his girlfriend's car when he was arrested in 2005 for "allegedly shooting Lamont Peterson multiple times at close range."
In 2012, a New Jersey state court of appeals was moved to overturn the 30-year conviction on the grounds that entering the lyrics (13 pages worth that were read out loud to the jury) as evidence was "highly prejudicial," resulting in Skinner getting a new trial.
Admittedly, the lyrics are extremely violent, painting a portrait of a cold-blooded killer, although they were written well before the incident and have no relation to Peterson:
"Two to your helmet and four slugs drillin' your cheek to blow your face off and leave your brain caved in the street — the seat. I play with fire like pyros and gasoline, so, come test one. I hope your brain got a rhino vest on. Death is your final step, Dawg, ain't nothin' sweet here, everywhere I go, I got my heat."
As noted by Business Insider, the conviction was overturned due to insufficient evidence, leading to the new trial, but as the ACLU of New Jersey points out, there have been 18 cases at courts around the country that considered rap lyrics as evidence, with the lyrics being allowed nearly 80 percent of the time. more on this story
Radio.com is an official news provider for antiMusic.com.