The problem with most CD reviews is you only get the opinion of the one critic doing the review. So we thought it might be fun to try something new here by giving the exact same CD to two different critics (or more) and see what they each come up with and just how much difference a single critic's opinion can make. 

This time around The Hobo and antiGUY give us their impressions of the new album from Adema.

Note: due to the nature of this series, the reviews may tend to be more in the first person than you are used to with music criticism.

Adema � Unstable
Label: Arista
 

Tracks:
Co-Dependant
Rip The Heart Out Of Me
Stand Up
Unstable
Promises
Blame Me
So Fortunate
Stressin� Out
Do You Hear Me
Let Go
Betrayed Me
Needles

The Hobo's review - he gave it a rating of:

What an uninspiring, boring, sterile and generic album. When our dear friend Scott Slapp grinded the band�s EP �Insomniac�s Dream�, I though it somewhat harsh. I briefly remembered hearing an Adema song months back, and while it rather bad, I did not think it warranted the flaming Slapp delivered (with, may I say, great finesse and flair). But I was wrong. So damn, damn wrong.

 �You have lost control
and crashed into a wall,
goto bed dead, goto bed dead�

Such are the amazingly insightful plunges deep into mankind�s clouded heart of darkness. Marky�s pathetically shallow, repetitive and base droning about his significant other grow old with a speed of such intensity, that the boredom itself breaks the speed of light, hence opening up a time warp of such power, that your very soul grows tired of its timeless existence.

The lyrics are pathetic. The guitar work exceeds the monotony and simplicity found in the disgraceful collection of popular punk bands. 

Marky�s voice itself is devoid of any interest or talent. Of special note is the single �Unstable�, which provides an apt dichotomy of the pitiful content of the album; at which I am deeply saddened I was asked to review. To end off the single Marky screeches, �you�re so unstable� over and over again. On the track immediately successive (a horrifyingly bad ballad) Marky ends the song repeating; �you�re so played out� in the exact � same � tone. These people test me. 

At times Adema sounds like Korn, minus any talent or originality, others like a skin puppet pop rock band. In any case, I weep for anyone unfortunate enough to hear this album. This album is just like a horrifyingly brutal and gory car crash � you know you don�t want to see it the dismembered limbs and assorted giblets, but you can�t avoid slowing down to examine the flaming wreckage. My advice to anyone curious about Adema is to save themselves the mental anguish and effort involved. It�s so bad I have considered placing out a public offer of $11,000 for anyone who brings me Marky Chavez�s spine.

Worst album of the year.

antiGUY's Review - He gave it a Rating of 

I wasn�t too impressed with Adema�s debut album. It was just one of those releases where the songs didn�t grab me and it sounded a bit too engineered towards making sales. My opinion of the group went up a few notches after I saw them live on the Music as a Weapon tour. The songs translated so much better live. It wasn�t just that there was more power behind them but on the disc is did seem like the band held back quite a bit, either that or the music was simply over produced. 

While they did get my attention with their live show, when I tried to relisten to their debut, my opinion of the disc still held firm. The songwriting just wasn�t that imaginative. The musicianship was pretty good, considering the genre of music, but the songwriting as whole seemed pretty generic. I was hoping they would put their best foot forward on their next release. 

Sadly, �Insomniac's Dream EP� fell short as well. In fact, in some ways it was a step backwards. But the group�s growing legions of fans ate it up and at the end of the day, it�s not what critics think but what the kids that buy the music think that counts, if you�re looking at the bottom line. 

Now we come to the group�s sophomore album, �Unstable�, and I have to say after a few spins that I was impressed on how much the group has grown in the songwriting department. There are some solid musical moments on here. �Co-dependant�, �Stand Up�, and �Betray Me �are compelling nu-metal songs with big choruses. �Blame Me� is another standout with it�s heavy to light dynamics. The big surprise comes with the two ballads, �Promises� and �Let Go�. These songs show the group�s real potential if they step outside of the box for a moment and try something new.  Although, put neck in neck against each other, �Promises� is the clear winner. �Let Go,� could have been a much stronger song if the lyrics weren�t so repetitive. 

That's the group's biggest weakness; the lyrics and repetitiveness. If you pay attention to the lyrics then Marky just may go down as Nu Metal's answer to Missy Elliot. 

For the most part, the nu-metal riffing is predictable but Adema do deliver in the melody department. Marky�s lyrics are still a bit insipid and he�s a really bad tendency to beat a line into the ground, but he�s getting better. 

Will Adema still be around in ten years? Given the recent history of the music industry, that�s up for debate but when it came time to deliver a stronger album than their debut, Adema did accomplish the task. 

Listen to samples and Purchase this CD online


advertisement

advertisement

News Reports
Day in Rock:
Rock Hall Nominees To Be Announced On American Idol- Clutch and Rival Sons Announce The Two-Headed Beast Tour- more

Dance Gavin Dance Part Ways With Frontman Tilian Pearson- Prong Rock Rush Classic 'Working Man' In New Video- more

David Lee Roth Streams New Song 'Scotch and Sofa'- Iron Maiden Have 'Top Secret' Plans For 2025 - Thursday Deliver First New Song Since 2011- more

Slash Teams With Chris Stapleton To Cover Fleetwood Mac's 'Oh Well'- Pearl Jam Expand One Night Only Event- Rolling Stones Streaming Documentary- more

Metallica Rock Tribute To Elton John and Bernie Taupin- Collective Soul Stream New Song 'Mother's Love'- Crowded House Share 'Teenage Summer' Video- more

Aerosmith Announce Rescheduled Peace Out Farewell Tour Dates- Deep Purple Recruit Yes For North American Tour- more

Ozzy Osbourne Launching New Show The Madhouse Chronicles- Pantera Pay Tribute To Dimebag and Vinnie Paul's Father Jerry Abbott- more

Day in Pop:



Reviews

• Savoy Brown - Ain't Done Yet

• Quick Flicks: The Center of Nowhere (The Spirit and Sounds of Springfield, Missouri)

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: 100 Dishes to Eat in Alabama

• RockPile: Neal Smith, Shadow & the Thrill, Limousine Beach and Vicious Rooster

• The Georgia Thunderbolts - The Georgia Thunderbolts EP

• Ozzy Osborne Was The Monster Under My Bed

• Sites and Sounds: Slaughterhouse 5 Opera Set For September Premiere

• MorleyView: Deep Purple's Roger Glover

• Laura Wilde - Charmed + Dangerous

• RSC - Shadow Lady

• On The Record: Hall & Oates, Triumph, Daniel Johnston, and Social Distortion

• Sonic Fuel - I Will Rise

• Sites and Sounds: Texas Country At Sea

• The Blues: Albert Castiglia - Wild and Free

• Daddy1 - 1 Bro Gad

• RockPile: Gang of Four- Half Past Two - Venus Furs

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: Road Trip Gear Edition, Part 2

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: Road Trip Gear Part 1

• Static-X - Project Regeneration Volume 1

• Rock Reads: 'Run-Out Groove: Inside Capitol's 1980s Hits & Stiffs' by Dave Morrell

• Psycle - Kill The Machine

• RockPile: Southern Rock Edition - Lynyrd Skynyrd, Allman Bros, Molly Hatchet, Marshall Tucker Band

• RockPile: Danielia Cotton, the Jackets And More

• Root 66: Chicago Farmer - Flyover Country

• Reggae Party

• Sundogs - The Code

• Root 66: Nate Lee - Wings of a Jetliner

• Mallavora - The Paradise EP

• The Burrito Brothers - The Notorious Burrito Brothers

• David Cross & Peter Banks - Crossover

• Dennis DeYoung - 26 East: Volume 1 � more

Rock News Stories
Rock Hall Nominees To Be Announced On American Idol

Clutch and Rival Sons Announce The Two-Headed Beast Tour

Converge Postpone Tour Following Kurt Ballou Hospitalization

Underoath Announce The 20th Anniversary Tour

Chevelle Reveal 2024 Summer Tour Plans

Boys Like Girls Recruit Grayscale For 2024 Headline Tour

Jinjer Preview Live In Los Angeles With 'Pisces' Video

Frank Turner To Attempt The World Record For Most Shows Played In Different Cities In 24 Hours

The Early November Share 'The Fool' Video

Singled Out: Southtowne Lanes' Witness

The Killers Lead of Sudden Little Thrills Music Festival Lineup

Joe Bonamassa Announces Rare One-Off UK Concert at The Anvil

Left to Suffer Announce New Album With 'Forever' Visualizer

Felicity To Deliver Pop Rock Anthem 'Lovesick Blues' Next Month

SiX By SiX Share 'The Mission' Video

Grand Slam Unleash 'Spitfire' Video

Tracheotomy Deliver 'Repercussions' With New Video

Can Continue Live Series With Live in Aston 1977

Lost Dog Street Band Take On Jim Ringer's 'Hubbardville Store'

Singled Out: Eric Knight's Out Of This World

� more

B-Side Stories
� more


Follow Us:

Contact Us - Privacy - antiMusic Email - Why we are antiMusic

Copyright© 1998 - 2016 Iconoclast Entertainment Group All rights reserved.

Please click here for legal restrictions and terms of use applicable to this site. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use.