The problem with most CD reviews is you only get the opinion of the one critic doing the review. So we thought it might be fun to try something new here by giving the exact same CD to two different critics (or more) and see what they each come up with and just how much difference a single critic's opinion can make. 

Note: due to the nature of this series, the reviews may tend to be more in the first person than you are used to with music criticism.

Bill Shatner returns to his true calling, music! For this go around of Tag Team, antiMusic critic Travis Becker teams with guest critic Marc Wiggins to take a listen to Has Been

William Shatner - Has Been
Label: Shout Factory Records

Common People - (with Joe Jackson)
It Hasn't Happened Yet
You'll Have Time
That's Me Trying - (with Aimee Mann)
What Have You Done
Familiar Love
Ideal Woman
Has Been
I Can't Get Behind That - (with Henry Rollins)

Travis Becker's review

Novelty records, more often than not, tend to end up like nasty car crashes.  They can be fun to ogle at a little, but ultimately they’re not such a good thing.  It’s hard to expect much more than a novelty record from an established actor and notable cult figure, such as William Shatner, especially after hearing his late sixties foray into popular music.  His new release, Has Been is not quite the loungy spoken-word tour de force that “The Transformed Man” was, but it’s still enough to make you giggle like there are Tribbles in your shorts and squirm like you’re watching “The Last Prom.”

The almost Rain Main-like pairing of Ben Folds and William Shatner does not feel like an “in” joke in the way that Shatner’s early effort did and it probably suffers some from the fact that Leonard Nimoy has yet to release the follow up to his own smash hit, the “Ballad of Bilbo Baggins.”  In other words, there is no context in this day and age for the record to feel witty or snickering.  The songs, which were mostly co-written by Shatner and a bevy of guest singers and musicians, are stronger as a whole and there are no cover tunes this time around.  The main effect of this lack of familiar material, however, is to make Bill’s intentions all the more vague.  Is this album a joke or has the skipper of the starship Enterprise actually decided to forego future Priceline endorsements and the inevitable T.J. Hooker feature film in favor of becoming a pop singer a la Regis Philbin?  Unfortunately, no answer is forthcoming.

Clearly some of the compositions are tongue-in-cheek and are meant to be so.  The contribution of Henry Rollins is a perfect example, it amounts to Hank and Captain Kirk blowing off steam about lousy music and getting old, but it’s obvious that the intrepid listener is meant to laugh.  Not so with the collaborations with Ben Folds and Joe Jackson which come across way too serious to be lumped in with the “Henry the Vth Elegy” of “Transformed Man.”  Indeed, the track, “That’s Me Trying,” could easily find a seat on the bench of a Ben Folds album with its all to real sentiments of love, loss, and the inability to communicate with the ones we love.  It’s “Brick” without the Yuletide abortion.

In the end what can you say about a new William Shatner album?  Did the world need it?  Probably not.  Does it have virtue in its own way?  Sure it does.  It’s a record that you can throw on during parties and get a good laugh, or while you’re driving to a Star Trek convention to get you in the mood to meet George Takei.  It’s not the roadside collision that most novelty albums are, heck it’s barely worth calling the state troopers for this little paint swap.  The only serious wreck that’s any threat from this release is the very real danger of hearing the song, “You’ll Have Time” while driving and then laughing so hard that the car careens into a ditch.  Only then will you understand the poignant message of that song. 

Marc Wiggins' review

William Shatner is a geek and that is meant in the best way.  Though he is best known as Captain Kirk, he is perhaps the most successful of television show leads to overcome his character type-cast.  Instead of associating him with Captain Kirk, I'm more inclined to smile at the cornball & self-effacing Priceline commercials and his famous appearance on Saturday Night Live where he jokingly told obsessed trekkies to get a life.  That SNL skit actually stirred up a bit of a controversy because some people took it as Shatner insulting a devoted following of his show's persona.  Personally, I think they misunderstood where he was coming from and a little unforgiving of the fact that he sometimes just simply has an off-the-wall sense of humor.  He wasn't insulting a TV show's fanbase in as much as he was making fun of himself and the notion that so many people took so much interest in something he was a part of.      

Bill Shatner took some heat from that now famous skit, jokes about his hair piece, countless stabs at his exaggerated mannerisms & speech rhythms from comedians and actors, and some mean spirited commentary from fellow Star Trek cast who competed for screen time.  Rather than being bitter or defensive about it, Shatner seemed to take it in good humor and even take an element of truth in those observations and turn them around to his favor by poking fun at himself. Though he did get a much better hairpiece.  

In that process of recognizing criticism and then having fun with it, it seems that maybe Shatner has figured out something about life that we can learn from. Rather than perpetuating the old glory days of a Starfleet Captain, expressing bitterness over a type-cast, or shrinking from criticism, he's moved on and even made all of that a part of who he is.  Nowadays, Bill seems to be expressing himself in good humor and without pretense.   He's fun to watch and maybe it's because here's a guy who enjoys the hell out of himself.  Shatner strikes me as a guy who makes every day a fun experience and doesn't waste too much time on the downside of things.  For a guy in his 70's, he seems to do a much better job at a taking fresh approach at life than many people much younger than himself.  This guy is taking life by the balls and enjoying everything it has to offer.

This leads us to Bill Shatner's new CD, Has Been.  In it, I was expecting an extension of parody we've all seen in his Priceline musical performances or the horrible albums he cut in the 60's.  I was surprised and delighted to hear much more dimension and a level of introspection that many artists who set out to convey but don't quite achieve.  In "Has Been," there are many fun songs as well as some haunting ones.  All of them actually make you think long after you hear them.

Thankfully, Shatner doesn't actually sing but rather speaks melodiously in his distinctive tone while backed up with the creatively diverse music of  Ben Folds.  All of the lyrics are written by Shatner with exception of the last song which interestingly is the only song that addresses his role in that famous TV show.  Each song is distinctive in subject matter and style but, as a whole, gives the listener a unique and better understanding of the artist.  This CD is more than a novelty and you may well find yourself often popping it in your player and not skipping over several tracks to get to the good ones as you would with many other CDs. 

The first song, "Common People," kicks off the CD in a hilariously fun way.  We, the listener, are obviously the 'Common People,' but the song pokes fun at those who place themselves above us.  The next song, "It Hasn't Happened Yet," immediately jumps into introspection that many of us can identify with--- the fear of failure and hoping to finally reach the point of success that that we think others would be proud of.  Next is the slightly morbid, "You'll Have Time," which is sung in gospel and repeats the line, "your 'gunna die."  It's a cautionary statement about not wasting your life, and there's something fun about blasting this song in your car and making people turn their heads in your direction with a 'What the Hell?' expression on their faces.  Following this is the very introspective, "That's Me Trying," which is Shatner trying to reconnect with the daughters he was not around enough for.  

Then comes a break with a very haunting haiku devoted to Bill's wife and the moment he had found her floating in their pool after her suicide.  This is followed by "Together," which is a pretty melody about his love for his wife.  Next is "Familiar Love," which is a love song and the only track I tend to skip over in the numerous times I've played this CD.  Things immediately pick up with "Ideal Woman," which is a hilarious song about the perfect woman but there's always something that isn't quite so perfect.  

"Has Been" is a fun song about the do-nothing critics who take glee at the failures of the famous or formally successful who can be famous again because, unlike the frustrated critics, they'll keep taking chances.  Next is "I Can't Get Behind That," which is a diatribe duet with Henry Rollins about the ridiculous things in life.  A fun thing Shatner can actually get behind is "so-called singers who can't carry a tune and get paid for talking", you gotta love it!  

The CD closes with "Real" which is a great country western 'sing-along' song about celebrities not being any more enlightened than their fans and how they can't save the world just because they're famous.  

Has Been is a great CD on many levels by an unlikely artist.  It's fun to listen to but with the diversity of subject matter, it will make you think about life and yourself as well as appreciating Bill Shatner in a way you've never before.  In playing this CD for a friend, his words summed it up quite nicely,  "Wow, there's more to this guy than I had thought."   

Listen to samples and Purchase this CD online

Check out the official site

And don't miss the Shatner "Has Been" eCard to preview the disc and more fun stuff



News Reports
Day in Rock:
Static-X Releasing The Final Recordings Of Wayne Static On New Album- Duran Duran Announce North American Tour- Pearl Jam- more

KISS's Paul Stanley and Ozzy Osbourne Super Bowl Commercial Goes Online- Megadeth To Livestream Budokan Concert- more

Ozzy Osbourne Reacts To His Grammy Wins- Disturbed North American Summer Tour- Ministry Recruits Gary Numan Spring Tour- more

Ozzy Osbourne Wins Two Grammy Awards- Fleetwood Mac Is Done Following Christine's Death- more

David Lee Roth Looks Back At Van Halen's Club Days- Peter Gabriel Marks Full Moon With New Song- Paul McCartney- more

Motley Crue First Photo Of New Lineup- Rock Hall CEO Thrilled Iron Maiden Nominated- Zakk Reacts To Ozzy Retirement- more

Slipknot Surprise Release New Single 'Bone Church'- Judas Priest React To Ozzy Osbourne Retiring-Bayside- more

Ozzy Osbourne Retires From Touring- Iron Maiden, Soundgarden, RATM Lead Rock Hall Nominations- more

Robert Plant and Alison Krauss Tour And Livestream- KISS- Lamb Of God Lead Resurrected Milwaukee Metal Fest- Fall Out Boy Tour- more

Day in Pop:


• Savoy Brown - Ain't Done Yet

• Quick Flicks: The Center of Nowhere (The Spirit and Sounds of Springfield, Missouri)

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: 100 Dishes to Eat in Alabama

• RockPile: Neal Smith, Shadow & the Thrill, Limousine Beach and Vicious Rooster

• The Georgia Thunderbolts - The Georgia Thunderbolts EP

• Ozzy Osborne Was The Monster Under My Bed

• Sites and Sounds: Slaughterhouse 5 Opera Set For September Premiere

• MorleyView: Deep Purple's Roger Glover

• Laura Wilde - Charmed + Dangerous

• RSC - Shadow Lady

• On The Record: Hall & Oates, Triumph, Daniel Johnston, and Social Distortion

• Sonic Fuel - I Will Rise

• Sites and Sounds: Texas Country At Sea

• The Blues: Albert Castiglia - Wild and Free

• Daddy1 - 1 Bro Gad

• RockPile: Gang of Four- Half Past Two - Venus Furs

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: Road Trip Gear Edition, Part 2

• Travel News, Trips and Tips: Road Trip Gear Part 1

• Static-X - Project Regeneration Volume 1

• Rock Reads: 'Run-Out Groove: Inside Capitol's 1980s Hits & Stiffs' by Dave Morrell

• Psycle - Kill The Machine

• RockPile: Southern Rock Edition - Lynyrd Skynyrd, Allman Bros, Molly Hatchet, Marshall Tucker Band

• RockPile: Danielia Cotton, the Jackets And More

• Root 66: Chicago Farmer - Flyover Country

• Reggae Party

• Sundogs - The Code

• Root 66: Nate Lee - Wings of a Jetliner

• Mallavora - The Paradise EP

• The Burrito Brothers - The Notorious Burrito Brothers

• David Cross & Peter Banks - Crossover

• Dennis DeYoung - 26 East: Volume 1 • more

Rock News Stories
Static-X Releasing The Final Recordings Of Wayne Static On New Album

Duran Duran Announce North American The Future Past Arena Tour

Pearl Jam Stream 1997 'Given To Fly' Rehearsal Video

Depeche Mode Confirm Support For North American Tour

Radiohead's Philip Selway Shares 'Strange Dance'

Alter Bridge Announce Spring US Tour Dates

Suicide Silence Share 'Dying Life' Video

Singled Out: Justin Mattock's Seventeen

• more

B-Side Stories
• more

Follow Us:

Contact Us - Privacy - antiMusic Email - Why we are antiMusic

Copyright© 1998 - 2016 Iconoclast Entertainment Group All rights reserved.

Please click here for legal restrictions and terms of use applicable to this site. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use.