Jealous Haters Since 1998!
Home | News | Reviews | Day In Rock | Photos | RockNewsWire | Singled Out | Tour Dates/Tix | Feeds

antiGUY's RANTitorial 
Nu Math and the R.I.A.A.
3-15-01 antiGUY

I just love it when people twist their numbers around in order to make a point, it’s even funnier when the press ignorantly goes along with the propaganda without taking a careful look at the numbers themselves. The latest example is the R.I.A.A., which in its ongoing battle with Napster has claimed in a round about way that their sales have declined because of fans stealing the music online**. The R.I.A.A. recently released their annual sales numbers and that claim doesn't add up unless you use nu math, which makes it possible for 2+2 to equal 37. But before we delve into the numbers lets take a look at the controversy that is Napster. 

While I have reported on the Napster issue several times, I have never publicly taken a stand for either side. The truth is, I can understand the stance of both sides, and so I am split on the verdict of whether Napster is a good thing or not. 

Personally I think of Napster as the modern equivalent of radio, it provides a platform for music to get out to the public. Radio these days is so market driven that fans only get to hear the “hit songs” which accounts for only a small percentage of the music that is released each year. Napster opens up the floodgates so to speak, so lesser known bands have the chance to get discovered by listeners. In that respect Napster is great. Then you have the bands or performers who don’t need this exposure and fans download the MP3’s so they won’t have to pay for the CDs, in this respect Napster is bad. By the same token, fans could just as easily tape the same song off of radio or burn a copy of someone else’s CD to avoid purchasing it for themselves. But I believe a great majority of people who discover songs they like from Napster do indeed go out and buy the full CD. This is evidenced by our unscientific survey on iconoFAN where we asked our readers if they have ever purchased a CD because they liked a song they heard on MP3. Over 80% said they have. So in that case, Mp3’s have acted just like radio and inspired fans to buy CD’s. 

With that in mind, the best solution to the Napster problem may be similar to what they proposed to the record industry, which is a royalty model similar to radio. Each time a song gets played on the radio the publisher of the song gets paid a small royalty. Since, I believe Napster is the modern equivalent to radio it makes sense to employ such a royalty model. So every time someone downloads the song xyz by the band efg they will generate a royalty payment. However, these payments could get out of hand and end up costing Napster a fortune if the same payment amounts are used. Plus add in the fact that radio makes their money from advertising and Napster proposes a subscription model to generate revenue, the radio royalty type system would have to be majorly tweaked in order to work, but it can be done.  For the artists that do not want their music traded on Napster, the company could employ the blocking filters they are now under court order to use, to keep those songs from being traded. 

Now lets look at the R.I.A.A.’s claim that Napster has caused a 38.8% decline in CD sales. That is just not true.  The 38.8% came from the decline in CD singles not full length CD’s.  Furthermore, CD singles only account for about 1% of the R.I.A.A.’s members sales. It is arguable that Napster has been a big cause of the decline in CD singles sales, but then you can also argue that the fans decided to buy the full length CD’s instead of the singles. Look at sales of performers who would normally be big hits in the singles market like N Sync and Eminem, looking at the millions of full length CD’s they sold, it is conceivable that fans opted to purchase the full CD instead of the one or two song single. Looking at Cdnow’s Eminem catalog they have for sale a full length CD for $14.99 which contains 18 tracks. They also are selling CD singles for $5.49 which only contain 5 tracks. So it would make sense that fans would opt to buy the 18 track CD for a little more money instead of the 5 track single. Looking at the broader picture though, singles are pretty outdated to begin with, they date back to the days when music was sold on vinyl and single 45’s sold for about 10% the cost of a full length LP. With CD singles they can cost almost a third of the cost of a full length CD. Wouldn’t it make more sense for the record industry to discontinue singles and sell the single songs for a buck or two online as downloads?  They would save a bundle on manufacturing, distribution and marketing which could translate into a windfall in revenue for the sale of digital singles. 

As for full-length CD sales in 2000, they were up 3.1% from 1999. While this is a sharp decline in growth (1999 sales grew 12.3% from 1998) it is still an increase and the decline in growth can also be partially attributed to a slowing economy the relatively small number of “hit” artists in 2000. Was Napster a part of this decline? It could have played a part but we will never know for sure. 

Continue
 

footnote: **(While they did not come right out and say this, the wording of their press release was done in such a way that it may appear the 38.8% applied to total CD sales. A few reporters did in fact read the release this way and included that assumption in their articles) 

--

.
News Reports
.
• Day in Rock:
Bayside Singer Hospitalized- More Pink Floyd Rarities?- Lost Stone Temple Pilots Clip- Bret Michaels Solo CD Features Def Leppard, Loretta Lynn and Jimmy Buffet- more

• Day in Pop Violent Madonna Stalker Escapes- Suge Knight Arrested- Gorillaz, James Murphy, and Andre 3000 Team Up- House Canceled- Taylor Swift Premiere Next Week- more

• B Sides: Howard Stern Van Halen Special Online- Ozzy Discusses Iommi's Cancer Battle on Radio Station Launch- Q&A With Slash- Lars Explains Metallica Experimenting- more

 Subscribe To Day in Rock

.
 
Reviews
.

• Tony K's Favorite Album's of 2011

• Road Trip: Feel the Magic - Alamos, Mexico's Festival Ortiz Tirado

• Elvis Found Alive

• Rock Reads: Dirty Deeds: My Life Inside/Outside of AC/DC

• Scorpions - Comeblack

• Room Service: Chicago, Ohio, Missouri and Quebec

• MorleyView: Ana Kefr

• A Marriage Between Music and Movies Part III: Cameron Crowe's Top 10 Greatest Hits

• RIP: Etta James - The Dreamer

• The Doors - Mr. Mojo Risin': The Story of L.A. Woman

• Soki2u - Dancing through the Needle's Eye

• Cameron Crowe's Greatest Hits Part II (25-11)

• Howlin' Wolf - Smokestack Lightning: The Complete Chess Masters 1951-1960

• Passport: Forty Winks- Giorgio Tuma- I Build Collapsible Mountains- Spring Offensive


.
.
.

Search for Tickets

Or Browse For Tickets

.
.
Today's Rock News
.

• Bayside Singer Hospitalized- More Pink Floyd Rarities Coming?- Mars Volta Preview- New Ratt This Summer- Dance Gavin Dance Guest Singers- Tommy Bolin and Friends- more

• Lost Stone Temple Pilots Clip Now Online

• Bret Michaels Solo CD Features Def Leppard, Loretta Lynn and Jimmy Buffet

• E Street Band Recruit Clarence Clemons' Nephew

• Ozzy Osbourne May Receive Hometown Honor

• Six Feet Under Lose Member

• Career Spanning Grateful Dead DVD Box Set Coming

• Ringo Starr's 13th All Starr Band Tour Dates

• Keith Richards, Eric Clapton, Buddy Guy To Tribute Hubert Sumlin

• Jack White and Tom Jones Tribute Howlin' Wolf

• Black Sabbath Day Backed By Culture Chief

• Sammy Hagar To Rum America

• Dave Grohl Sings Adele's Praises

• Miracles, Crickets and Other Famed Backing Bands To Rock The Hall

• Prong New Album Details

• Evile To Tribute David Gold This Weekend

• Van Halen Release TV Commercial

• Clutch Releasing Double Vinyl Edition Of Blast Tyrant

• Viral Hardcore Kids Video Battle

• Tombs Expand Tour Plans

• Dio Inspired American Idol's James Durbin

• Maps & Atlases Set New Album Release

• Iwrestledabearonce Get Warped

• We Are Augustines To Rock Letterman

• The Temper Trap Coming To America

• Merrell Fankhauser Releases Best Of The Tiki Lounge DVDs

• Remembering Sweet's Brian Connolly

• Singled Out: Lillian Axe's Caged In

Subscribe to Day in Rock Report by Email

.
.
Today's Pop News
.

• Violent Madonna Stalker Escapes- Gorillaz, James Murphy, and Andre 3000 Team Up- House Canceled- Taylor Swift Premiere Next Week- more

• Suge Knight Arrested

• Special Limited Edition Katy Perry Coming

• Halle Berry Death Threats

• Jersey City Cops Going on Snooki Patrol

• Scotty McCreery Up For Academy of Country Music Award

• Nate Dogg's Rapper Friends Didn't Have His Back?

• Another Chad Ochocinco Name Change Coming

• Remix Beyonce and Win

• Glee Tree Hugger Video Surfaces

• Erasure Fill Us With Fire

• Caveman Set For North American Tour

• Michael Lohan Applied for Job at Burger King

• Home Improvement Star Charged With DUI and Drug Possession

• American Idol Dad Wasn't In Rehab

• Labrinth Teams With Busta Rhymes For US Debut

• $30 Million for Matt Lauer?

More News

.
 
anti Worthy Links
.
• The Screen Door • superLOUD • A Journal of Musical Things • Lloyd Zeffler blog • Demolish Mag • Nightwatcher's House of Rock • CJ Chilvers • Deja Voodoo • The 1st Five • thecopycat.biz • Day in Rock @twitter

.
  .
.

Click Here to Buy T-Shirts!
Click Here to Buy T-Shirts!



 

Tell a Friend about this page - Contact Us - Privacy - antiMusic Email - Job Postings - Advertising - Why we are antiMusic

Copyright© 1998 - 2012 Iconoclast Entertainment Group All rights reserved. antiMusic works on a free link policy for reprinting of our original articles, click here for details. Please click here for legal restrictions and terms of use applicable to this site. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use.