Still a staple on rock radio and covered by a slew of artists, "Creep" is a song the band notoriously shies away from now, rarely performing it in concert.

The show's version featured characters Brody (Dean Geyer) and Rachel (Lea Michele) singing the song as a duet, and stays mostly faithful to the original Radiohead arrangement.

Believe it or not, the song was used as part of a "guilty pleasures" episode, with Broadway baby Rachel somehow believing one of the most critically-acclaimed bands in the world is a guilty pleasure. To give it a little perspective, some of the other guilty musical pleasures highlighted on the episode included Phil Collins and ABBA.