Disclaimer: the opinions
expressed are those of the author, not necessarily those of antiMUSIC,
or the iconoclast entertainment group
The Orange Bowl, a chorus of boos directed
at Ashley Simpson that drowned out any for a negative call made by a ref
that way against either team. The ‘Poison’ of reality TV stars, there
is an interesting parallel between the hair metal of the later 1980s and
Ashley Simpson in context of saturation- wherein carbon copies have gone
into their third or fourth generation in a matter of only a few short years,
and are finally starting to taper out. It happened between 1987 and
1991 as Poison degenerated into Warrant who deteriorated even further into
the likes of Ugly Kid Joe and Trixter before dying out completely.
Its happening again in 2005- though it began in the very late 1990s with
the dawn of Britney Spears, N’synch and the protools-generated pop star,
degenerated from there to Reality-TV launched pop stars like Jessica Simpson,
and finally has bottomed out with Ashley Simpson, who was pitched via her
show as an “Alternative” Jessica, a pop star with an indie edge along the
lines of Pink, who ironically CAN SING, successfully sold herself commercially
as an alternative to Britney by being just that, the antithesis.
In the case of Ashley Simpson, this is a second-generation sales gimmick,
with a B-List star who possesses almost no natural singing or songwriting
ability whatsoever, whose first demos were rejected by Geffen Records ON
HER SHOW to back up that fact. Saturday Night Live only served to
confirm this fact. The Orange Bowl was just the public finally lashing
back! No one is suggesting that Ashley doesn’t think she can sing,
most likely because her sister actually does possess the basic qualities
of an A-list pop star which Ashley has been convinced she’s inhereted.
Her father is her manager, so there’s almost no objectivity going on there,
only Yes-men surrounding this example of why pop music is desperately crying
out for its next revolution. Hopefully that revolution will crush
Ashley Simpson and all the Lindsay Lohans and Hilary Duffs like her into
some kind of permanent oblivion- a strange, akward phase pop music went
through at the turn of its next century that we excuse like we did the
continued existence of outhouses in the early 1900s before toilets were
available widespread in the 1920s in both urban and rural areas.
Thankfully, today we have high-speed toilets available to flush crap like
Ashley Simpson’s record and existence as a pop star right down into the
sewer where they belong. Milli Vanilli had more credibility as showmen!
They won a Grammy, and had the decency to give it back when it was shown
they didn’t actually perform their own music on record. How is Ashley
Simpson any different when Protools features like autotune and pitch correction
exist to hide the fraud Simpson’s voice would otherwise be exposed as to
A&R men who then would have stopped the tragedy of her pop scorge before
it occured.
Its time, and all the signs are clear-
pointing us to the trash dump where Ashley Simpson- as a performer- and
all like her belong! I wish I was a major label or a millionaire so I could
underwrite one of those radio campaigns where you can bring down your copy
of a protested album, and turn it in for a refund of your money or a credit
of equal value toward another artist... At least her sister Jessica
is HOT, and Britney has a dope, DOPE body! What does Ashley have
physically to compensate for her lackluster voice? Not much as far
as I can see. I know its superficial and somewhat cruel on the surface
to point this out, but its valid in context of the role looks typically
play in commercially breaking pop stars who can’t naturally carry a tune.
Thankfully for Ashley Simpson, she’s only 20, she’s made some money, and
her career appears to be heading toward the doom it has earned and naturally
deserves, so she has plenty of time to choose another career. From
her reality show, she doesn’t look very bright, and isn’t cute about that
part of her personality the way Jessica is, so who knows what else she
can do? At least we all have that in common- desepration. Rolling
Stone Magazine rated her debut album, ‘Autobiography’ a lackluster 2 stars
out of 5, and pointed out that “the music's (a) mundane melange of Avril-ish
brat pop and Sheryl Crow cod rock reaches its nadir (or lowest point) on
‘Love Me For Me.’ ” No thanks Ashley! For the public at large,
she’s playing on our last nerve- because nobody gives a shit what music
is playing at a football game, they usually ALWAYS cheer no matter who
it is! You know it must have sucked for Ashley Simpson to inspire
such a thunderous BOO! Let’s all do it collectively, BOOOO!!!!!!
Now maybe Simpson, for once, will hear the music, smell what she’s singing,
and start stepping out of the pop music game forever, for the sake of us
all, and herself!
Shameless Plug: “Dust N’ Bones:
The Untold Story of Izzy Stradlin” is now available for Pre-order.
The one and only book on Guns N’ Roses legendary rhythm guitar player and
songwriter, this biography is a must-have for any GnR fan! Please
visit www.blackmarketpublishing.com
for more details!
Posted by Heather:
Jake, from reading this my first thought was you were definitely a teenage girl. Why a grown man cares enough to write an extensive & dull article about this, I do not know. Except that you may secretly be jealous and wish you were an untalented teenage girl with millions in the bank? I’m not even a fan of Ashley Simpson!
Posted by umy :
omg she rocks and thats all i have to say
Posted by nickflick:
ASHLEY SIMPSON needs to GIVE IT UP!! She needs to go to college and get an education so she could a good job makeing real money like the rest of the citizens of the USA. Anyways this girl has to give it up. GEEEK
Posted by thesubliminalverse.:
forgive me if i'm wrong, but i'm pretty sure she wasn't singing by herself on SNL. she deserves all the crap she gets for that because hey, anyone can sing karaoke. and if you call that ridiculous "hoedown" she did after being caught red-handed on SNL 'dancing', then my god, she's good at something! and "made a few mishaps"? she's a fraud, plain and simple. her voice is nasal and doesn't even come close to having the singing talent her sister does. man, i feel sorry for all you people that still need to be saved from her. come to the dark side! RIP Dimebag. reverend, reverend, is this some conspiracy? crucified for no sins. It's sad how we lost such a great artist so soon.
Posted by red:
all u peeps dat iz giving ashley crap needs to stop. y dont u try to get in front ov peeps and dance and sing if its so easy. all i am saying iz u need to get off ashleys butt bout SNL
Posted by redbean_mafia12:
but further more... ashley is quite ok...
I mean she's good!
Posted by redbean_mafia12:
guns and roses are too old! They sucks!
eeww...
Posted by Amy:
Hi is anyone there
Posted by todd:
How long do we have to endure this no talent BUTT CLOWN? there are plenty of artists who can sing and write their own songs so why should we have this loser forced on us before we stand up and say... This is BULL CRAP!!!
Posted by MusicMan:
Ashley Simpson should have to refund money to all the 2 plus million people that bought into her fake crap! I wonder how many million dollar voice changers and sythesizers, etc.. it took to get her voice on the album she produced? It is a dam shame that anyone who has a little money backing them can be made up into a so called pop star. People are paying hard earned money to premote these people like Ashley and she defrauds them. I cannot be part of a class action suit because I never bought into that album! When you have two people from the same house wanting to be pop stars..BEWARE!! We don't need these problems in an industry that is doing it's best to stop pirating, etc..
Posted by MusicMan:
Ashley Simpson should have to refund money to all the 2 plus million people that bought into her fake crap! I wonder how many million dollar voice changers and sythesizers, etc.. it took to get her voice on the album she produced? It is a dam shame that anyone who has a little money backing them can be made up into a so called pop star. People are paying hard earned money to premote these people like Ashley and she defrauds them. I cannot be part of a class action suit because I never bought into that album! When you have two people from the same house wanting to be pop stars..BEWARE!! We don't need these problems in an industry that is doing it's best to stop pirating, etc..
Posted by TK:
Note that all the Ashlee Simpson-defenders sound like a bunch of idiot 10 year olds. "OH, shes not dumb. and shes a gooood singer!! i loooove ashlee!!" Those people, along with ashlee, should be flushed.
Posted by a girl:
dinomyte, she's not going to improve. She HAS NO TALENT.
Posted by SATANFAG:
JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE IS YOUR MASTER! MASTER!!!
Posted by dinomyte:
I love Ashley. Just because she made a few mishaps doesn't mean she should quit now. Think of the countless other who have done it and gotten away with it. She is a great singer and she will continue to improve if we give her the chance.
Posted by satanhasboobs:
We should focus the torches and pitchforks on the morons who actually be their f**king records. The are the real problem!
Posted by liv-ya:
i think she is only famous becuase of her sister.... she is ALWAYS OFF KEY when she sings!!!! get some lessons!!!!
Posted by Jim Bob the Slob:
Rolling Stone: If you were to go to hell, what song would be playing over and over?
Nikki Sixx: "Anything by Ashlee Simpson."
Posted by presidentpoopyhead:
I just want to say that, no I don't like Ashley Simpson. But I also equally hate Jessica Simpson. Has anyone actually watched or listened to her sing? She looks so unbelievably stupid the way she jerks around and bobs her head. Ashley jirates and jerks her pelvis around and just makes herself look so silly. Both of these girls, as far as I'm concerned, should go back to that small world of Baptist churches and pretend to be good Christians. Has anyone noticed that their Dad is a Baptist youth minister? What is up with this family and the two worlds they're trying to represent? Make the Simpsons disappear, (and I don't mean Bart and Homer.)
Posted by Bryan:
Ashley is so Wak, That was the most right on paper about her and what a pleasure to read. Its Perfect!
Posted by Serge:
She sucks the big one
Posted by spiderman:
ashley simspon is such fake. she can't even sing. she reminds me of the fat girl of the osbournes.
Posted by Bartman:
Nice take, before you totaly flush yor senses of this little wretch, read the article in Jan/05 Cosmo- she's the cover-(hooker)-girl and the article reads like she ended terror by herself and the whole world is dying to give her another lip-sync chance to win thier hearts- it'll make you ill-this is what she would do with even the slightest amount of true earned fame- ignore every chance to be a responsible icon, and go shopping! What a pig!!!
Posted by muisc:
I hate Ashlee Simpson. She cant sing and she isnt hot. Bah it makes me mad. I found her SNL and Orange Bowl mishapps freaking hilarious!!!!
Posted by Bunzo Steel (aka Sexmaster 2000):
Stick a black pointy hat on her and give her a broomstick. Viola! Instant witch. Only bring her out on Halloween.
Posted by Jake, author of Smackdown:
http://www.stopashlee.com
You all have GOT to go sign this thing- this is hilarious, but reamplifies my point about AS- over 100,000 signatures to date have been collected!!!
Posted by Caught in a Mosh:
From my thinking and reading, this is what I've come up with as far as knowledge in pop music:
- Along with Rap, majority of Emo/Pop-Punk and the majority of Nu-metal, Pop is a tool of MTV and other big corporations
- The popular crowd isnt looking deep into music, they are eating the Avrils and Ashlees right up, and really do think it has meaning. Sure some of it I can see relating to, but its all about the same thing. No variety in song meanings, its all OMFG MY BOYFRIEND DITCHED ME what am i gonna do. Buy new music thats what. Nothing thats serious, just some type of thing that sounds like everything else, no talent
- The reason why there is no variety is because the record labels and MTV dont want variety. If we all like the same thing, we all buy the same thing, making $$$ for the a$sholes. They dont want music, they want everything to be similar, so we all buy the same sh!t.
- No talent. Protools and auto pitch everywhere. Ashlee can't sing at all, just by having big boobs(or a sister with big boobs) you can make records, and by having good looks you are attractive in your videos which get overplayed, and by doing that its more consumer-friendly.
- Instruments sound the same, no interest there its all put on the voice, with some type of noise that in some way fits the voice, its fine. This goes along with no talent but as a guitarist i think that it deserved a section.
- No work put into it. Again its the protools thing, but it really doesnt take effort to make these songs.
- However, slowly will implode, and suddenly there will be some kicka$s bands coming to take its place. After the early 70's/late 60's with Hendrix and Zepplin there was a whole bunch of sh!t, Kiss came out, a whole ton of pop, all that dumb sh!t. A few good bands came in the early 80's/late 70's, like Motorhead and AC/DC(around before but still, BACK IN BLACK). Then you really had sh!t, it was motley crue and all those morons, but underground you had the best musical genre created, THRASH. however to get rid of all the sh!t was Grunge, although not the best, Soundgarden and Alice in Chains are much preferred over the crue. You see its only a metter of time before some type of actual music comes along and obliterates this trend.
Posted by GREENMUSE:
um,yaytopop?"The only reason they are where they are is because of who they know."i sure hope to bob this was meant as sarcasm.if not...slowly rethink what you just said and who you said it about.
Posted by Brenna:
Iluv ashley simpson she is a great singer just cuz not everybody likes her doesnot mean she should step down i think this is just the begining of her
Posted by POPTART:
Thats right Shoebag, and thats how every great rock n roll band started out. its too bad pop has always been given prefference to rock. its just a sad fact that black music and pop is so easy to make nowadays that almost no talent at all is necessary
Posted by yaytoPOP:
Im glad i have a girl that is beautiful (in my eyes), can sing and has intelligence, integrity and cares more about others than herself. Too bad all these girls care about is themselves, getting the limelight, getting plastic surgery. I dont respect anyone who doesnt work hard to get to where they are. Thats why i dont respect Bush, Ashley or Paris. The only reason they are where they are is because of who they know.
Posted by Shoebag:
Why so much animosity towards Ashley and her pop counter parts? I'll tell you why: real artists in bands that make great music and start from NOTHING, touring across the U.S. in a van that continually breaks down, living off of the merch money to eat, and spending countless hours in the studio to make great records don't get half the recognition or exposure as these Teen Queens. These daddy's girls don't need anything (especially talent) because they have a band to play all the music their producer writes for them and "auto tune" in Protools if her voice sucks. I don't think this is mainly aimed at Ashley, but she is the new "poser" poster child. And for the many hours I have been bombarded with her music and TV show, I figure she owes me that time back. She can start by going away. Thank you, good night.
Posted by Out in the Cold:
Oh your just jealous, she sold 2-3 million copies, has a successful TV show, etc. and you wish that your daddy had done the same for you. Whatever happened to the notion of "Live and let Live". If you don't like it, don't look at it, listen to it, etc. The girl has a right to make a living, and no one has the right to take that away even if she does suck huge donkey weiners, both as a singer and actress. Yes her 15 minutes should be nearing the end, but until then we should just grin and bear it.
Posted by Buffybuff:
Shoot them all? While I don't care for Britney, Jessica or Ashlee, I certainly don't advocate shooting them. After Dimebag Darrell's murder, saying stuff like that just isn't funny anymore, even if it's about artists we don't like.
Posted by LithiumBliss:
Why single out Ashlee? Britney and Jessica are just as bad. And I don't think either Simpson is "hott". Just because you can give a girl fake bleach blonde hair and big fake jugs doesn't make her a hottie. Jessica's face looks like it was chiseled from granite, with a Kurt Douglas chin. And none of these teenybop hottie singers can really sing. Shoot them all!
Posted by Shoebag:
Hope that bitch saved the money from those "Eclipse Mint" comercials, cause the ride is offically over.
Posted by pop will eat itself :
This current pop phenomena is very fu@king disturbing. Who supports this dribble; then goes out of their way to buy this crap. Just discussing it sh%tz me to tears. I cannot take much more of this mainstream teen pop krud and those winkholes that profit from it. When are kids & teens going to listen to & demand decent music. Something needs to change, or it must be near time for the apocalypse. How could Rolling Stone even rate it in the first place? The RS reviewer obviously didn't give it a full listen since a brain aneurysm would've resulted (then again that would explain the 2 stars).
Posted by The Metal Lord:
Right on!!
Posted by The Evil Mr Grog:
Dude, she should have never released an album in the first place, just because her Sister is famous for bieng a dumb sh*t doesen't mean its okey too impose another peon related to her upon the world.