A clip of the band in the studio premiered last night on Jimmy Kimmel Live! which shows the late night host coming by to help frontman Brandon Flowers and the guys hit all the right notes.

This includes wearing the appropriate ugly sweater, making sure Flowers is singing into the mic and accurately telling this particular lump of coal's story. "Imagine you're an old Jewish grandmother," Kimmel suggests to Flower so he gets the pronunciation of the name just right.

Kimmel gets to play Santa Claus, while Flower makes it clear Joel isn't so bad, singing, "He just wants to keep Santa warm/ And make the elves cozy." Maybe it wouldn't be that bad to get a lump of coal in your stocking after all.