Standing between August Wilson and Neil Simon theaters, Sting fittingly surprised pedestrians by joining the cast for The Police's "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic."

An energetic number complete with confetti, the cast even managed to get a few New Yorkers involved in the sing-along. Streetgazers were in luck because that wasn't the only sidewalk performance of the night. After the performance of Sting's 1981 hit the cast then performed a choreographed number of "All Night Long" from The Last Ship.