antiMusic Logo
Jealous Haters Since 1998!
Home | News | Reviews | Day In Rock | RockNewsWire | Singled Out | Feeds
spacer
 

with DeadSun

You've seen him in Fan Speak all around the antiMUSIC network, now DeadSun gets his big show as the host of his very own talk show,  The Not Quite-So DeadShow ! Forget Oprah and Dr. Phil, DeadSun knows how to liven up a talk show. 

.

disclaimer for lawyers and dumbasses:
Please read the disclaimer before proceeding with this article. the disclaimer is included here-in by reference.
If you are under the age of 17, this article is not meant for you so please bugger off.
For those too lazy to click what follows is parody and celebrity a**holes are impersonated
.

Nu Metal: Where Did it Go Wrong?

Nu metal is dying.

In fact, the signs indicating that it was on its last leg started to linger around 2003, when record sales from the ubiquitous, big money acts began to dwindle. What happened? I suppose the answer lies buried somewhere in between the culmination of the style, and it having been a frequent target of acute criticism from heavy metal fans worldwide. Simply stated: a lot of people, especially long term fans of metal, had it in for nu metal from the beginning. So what exactly is it about nu metal that so many take issue with? Does the evidence of its (comparatively speaking) decline in mass-popularity vindicate those who have--- all along--- not only put nu metal down as wanting in technique, but adamantly declared much of it to be little more than the latest hatchling from the minds of market analysts? In this month's editorial, I intend to explore the possible answers to these questions, and I intend to do so as fairly as possible.

"Nu metal"--- we've all heard it before. The phrase itself is generally acknowledged to have been coined by Korn frontman Jonathan Davis, to describe an (at that time) emerging sound/style--- what he referred to as "new URBAN metal". 

This novel coinage of Davis' begs a question. Why the inclusion of the word "urban"? In my mind, this leads to even more questions. Was metal, prior to the mid-1990's, somehow "un-urban"? This inference seems ridiculous on its face. Correct me if I'm mistaken, but didn't bands like Metallica, Slayer, and Exodus cut their teeth in the Bay Area of California? Didn't Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, Black Sabbath and Motorhead plant their gardens in British cities like Birmingham, London, and Manchester? Can it get much more "urban" than San Francisco or Birmingham?

Of course, I'm being coy. "Urban", in this case, was Davis' euphemistic substitute for hip hop culture, something that nu metal has hitherto been rife with--- whether this is "good" or "bad" is a judgment that can only be left to the devices of the individual. The point is this--- from its inception, the name itself was intentionally obscure, however the impressions soon became palpable enough; oversized pants, the pimp-esque jogging suits, the gold chains, the sideways baseball hats, vocals offered up in rap format, the presence of the obligatory "kicker-box beat", the absence of noteable guitar presence in favor of beefed up basslines, the employment of a DJ, etc.

... and all the while, most metal fans were scratching their heads. I was one of them. Record executives weren't, though. During the mid-1990's, they were all-too aware of hip hop's growing market share and--- let us not forget--- hip hop's relatively low production costs. I believe the search went out for cross-over acts who could potentially tap into the hard rock and heavy metal markets. These markets were observably hung over from the enormity of the early 90's "grunge" swell which, by that time, had begun to recede. Even still--- the alternative rock explosion of the late 80's/early 90's offered up much more than whatever was coming out of Seattle at the time--- and in a few exceptionally rare instances, the labels took notice as MTV took notice.

Enter the band Faith No More, and their blockbuster video for the genre-bending song "Epic".

Considered by most to be the earliest crystallization of nu metal, "Epic" was (unfortunately for a truly avant-garde outfit like Faith No More) the model prototype of what more than a few AR label recruiters were looking to tap. And tap they did. That is not to put forward the idea that Faith No More was the sole catalyst behind what ultimately morphed into the nu metal of Jonathan Davis' description. Quite the contrary. 

One can, with little effort of thought, hear the seeds of nu metal being formulated in the earlier works of bands like Godflesh, Helmet, Faith No More, Rage Against the Machine, Sepultura (Chaos AD and Roots in particular), the Melvins, and even the Swans--- at least from the heavier, musical side of things. What we somehow ended up with, by the late 1990's, was Korn, Limp Bizkit, Papa Roach, Linkin' Park, Deftones, Crazy Town, et al. With that taken into account, I often find myself bewildered that nu metal evolved the way it did. My ears tell me that the resulting product did not proceed logically from its root sources of inspiration, almost like a tree that grows in the shape of a letter "Z". I have often--- to the shock and consternation of many a metalhead--- put forward the notion that nu metal might have evolved into something that was more than just a novelty act with generic (and hence) popular appeal and a "tuff" name, had it opted for the avant-garde mission statement of bands like Godflesh, Melvins, and Faith No More. Instead, it collectively aligned itself with the most transparent gimmicks associated with mainstream hip hop culture--- just look around. It isn't difficult to see the blatant level of saturation. Bad move. Metal fans don't tend to jump the trains of popular trend, all because a few marketing drones dangle a glossy video before them. 

This did nothing but repel them. 

How unsurprising, then, that the greater part of the fanbase which nu metal sought out and ultimately attracted are consummate trend hoppers, who--- even the TOP end of the spectrum--- typically have a four year attention span for something, until they race off to latch onto the next "like, uber hot" novelty. This calls to mind the similar, self-inflicted fate that dealt glam metal a death blow by the dawn of the 1990's. Once again, the artists took the easy bait. Now sales are winding down. People are losing interest. Too bad. Maybe there would have been fewer platinum albums along the way, but if nu metal acts had taken a more creative, substantive approach to structure and style, it might not have found itself--- in mere few years--- relegated to obscurity, only occasionally resurrected to serve as a punchline. So much for doing what is best to preserve in earnest. 

It is interesting that, among its fans--- I've noticed that the phrase "nu metal" has lately become a dirty word of sorts--- another indication that portends its pending demise. All of a sudden, people go on the defensive when a band is referred to as a nu metal band. Have you noticed that in many instances--- to its fans--- "nu metal" is no longer a viable classification, but when administered, is now viewed as a negative stereotype? Clearly, a shift in perception has taken place since the late 1990's. Many now prefer to bury nu metal underneath the misleading term "alternative metal". Be on the lookout for that one, because it's coming into vogue. This falls under that age old magic trick: "If we call it something else, people will believe that it is something else." It isn't alternative metal. I also find it curious that, to my knowledge, nobody seemed to mind the classification so long as sales were booming, and advertising one's music as "nu metal" meant a better chance at getting noticed by a big label. So what's different between THEN and NOW?

This is fairly black and white--- nu metal is running out of steam, and those who oil the gears are looking for ways to wring a few more years out of it. Renaming it is one such way.

Therein lies the problem--- if nu metal is going to stay alive, cosmetic changes aren't going to be the solution. Changes need to take place within the music. 

The sound needs to break its mould. 

Will it?

It's doubtful.

DS
 
 
 
 


advertisement
advertisement

.
News Reports
.

Day in Rock:
Video Of Ritchie Blackmore's New Rainbow Shows Go Online- Megadeth's Nick Menza Tribute Show Now Unlikely?- At The Drive-In Cancel Tour- AC/DC With Axl- Metallica- more

Beyond Rock: Chuck D Says Kanye West Helped Turn Hip-Hop Into A Disgrace- Troy Ave Reportedly Indicted On Five Felony Charges- Carrie Underwood's New 'Sunday Night Football' Theme- more

Led Zeppelin Win Stairway To Heaven Trial- Guns N' Roses Reunion Tour Kick Off Show Video Goes Online- Blink-182 Streaming New Song 'No Future'- Bring Me The Horizon- more

 Subscribe To Day in Rock


advertisement

.
Rock News Stories
Led Zeppelin Win Stairway To Heaven Trial

Guns N' Roses Reunion Tour Kick Off Show Video Goes Online

Blink-182 Streaming New Song 'No Future'

Bring Me The Horizon Release 'Avalanche' Video

Jeff Beck Streams New Song 'Live In The Dark'

Iggy Pop Hints At Retirement From Music

Memphis Horns Icon Wayne Jackson Dead At 74

Tesla Announce Mechanical Resonance Live!

The Eagles and James Taylor Lead 2016 Kennedy Center Honorees

HBO Cancel Mick Jagger Executive-Produced Series Vinyl

Blackfoot Announce First Album In 22 Years 'Southern Native', Stream Song

Young Guns Announce New Album 'Echoes'

Delain Reveal 'Moonbathers' Album Details

Wolverine Streaming New Song 'Pledge'

Rammstein Release 'Du Riechst So Gut' Live Video

Tarja Turunen Releases 'Innocence' Video

Brand X Announce Reunion Tour Plans

Motionless In White Giving Away New Single '570'

Barock Project Singer Luca Pancaldi Leaves The Group

Singled Out: Barry Hyde (The Futureheads)

Great White Frontman Drank Himself Into A Coma

Tom DeLonge Talking To Travis Barker About Blink-182 Future

Led Zeppelin Stairway To Heaven Case Now In Jury's Hands

Five Finger Death Punch's Jason Hook Cast As FBI Agent In Film

Avenged Sevenfold, Volbeat, Killswitch Engage and Avatar Tour

Late Megadeth Star Nick Menza's Art Collection To Be Unveiled

Every Time I Die's New Album Features Brendon Urie

Staind Frontman Aaron Lewis Releasing New Solo Album

Other Music News Stories
Dave Grohl Saved By Taylor Swift At Paul McCartney's House

Tom DeLonge Inserted Into Blink-182's New Video By Fan

Fall Out Boy Stream Their Version Ghostbusters Theme Song

Imagine Dragons 'Sucker for Pain' Video Ft. Lil Wayne, Wiz Khalifa

50 Cent and Chris Brown Release 'No Romeo No Juliet' Video

Alice In Chains Ponder Post Guns N' Roses Tour Plans

Twisted Sister Release You Can't Stop Rock 'n' Roll Live Video

Five Finger Death Punch Made Major Changes To Help Moody's Battle

Randy Bachman Wrote 'American Woman' On Stage

FOES Release 'The Everest' Music Video

Marillion's Steve Rothery Limited Edition Postcards From The Road

Converse All Star Shoe Mashed Up With Wah Wah Pedal

Volbeat's Michael Poulsen On Challenges Of Lineup Changes

Calysta Bevier Talks About Her 'America's Got Talent' Tryout

Rob Thomas Launches Interactive Hologram Karaoke Fan Experience

Fergie Previews 'Hungry' from Upcoming 'Double Dutchess'

Def Leppard Release 'Man Enough' Video

Judas Priest's Rob Halford Talks 'Controversial' Rock Hall

Motorhead Star Reflects On Lemmy's Legacy

Judith Hill Thought She Saw Prince Die

TLC Making First New Album in 14 Years

Drake Cancels Summer Sixteen Tour Meet & Greets

Levin Minnemann Rudess Preview New Album

Kurt Cobain Art Exhibition Tour In The Works

Purple Streaming New Song 'Love Maker'

Deftones' Chino Moreno Talks Blended Sensory Approach To Songwriting

Tarja Turunen Previews 'Innocence' Video

Brett Eldredge Releases 'Wanna Be That Song' Video

Reviews
All Recent Reviews and Interviews

The Blues: Walter Trout - Alive in Amsterdam

Quick Flicks: Johnny Winter With Dr. John - Live in Sweden 1987

Get To Know... Madysin Hatter

RockPile: Bun E. Carlos- Crown Jwlz- The Last Ditches

Jack Hues and the Quartet - Collaborations Vol. 3: A Thesis on the Ballad

Beninghove's Hangmen - Pineapples and Ashtrays

Motorhead - Clean Your Clock

Turning Virtue - A Temporary Human Experience

TBT: Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band Live 2006

Post Death Soundtrack - The Unlearning Curve

Rock Reads: Aliens Among Us: Exploring Past and Present

RockPile: Prog Edition (Asia, Security Project, The Raptor Trail)

Abominable Putridity - The Anomalies of Artificial Origin

Jean Michel Jarre - Electronica 2: The Heart of Noise

Rock Reads: Trouble Boys: The True Story of the Replacements

MorleyView Marty Balin (Jefferson Airplane)

Red Tide Rising - Voices

Denner Shermann - Satan's Tomb

The Blues: Blind Lemon Peel Blues All-Stars - Don't Tear My Clothes

Steve Porcaro - Someday/Somehow

Kiefer Sutherland Live

The Allman Brothers Band - Live From A&R Studios, New York, August 26, 1971

Howardian - A Smurf at Land's End

Anvil is Anvil

Album of the Week: Generation X

Root 66: Darryl Purpose - Still the Birds

Quick Flicks: The Dollyrots - Family Vacation: Live in Los Angeles

5 Star Friday: Searching for Sugar Man

Rock Reads: Show Posters: The Art and Practice of Making Gig Posters

Vehemence - Forward Without Motion

Ben Craven - Last Chance to Hear

The Rides - Pierced Arrow

Contact Us - Privacy - antiMusic Email - Why we are antiMusic

Copyright© 1998 - 2016 Iconoclast Entertainment Group All rights reserved.

Please click here for legal restrictions and terms of use applicable to this site. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use.